gh-113320: Reduce the number of dangerous getattr() calls when constructing protocol classes (#113401)

- Only attempt to figure out whether protocol members are "method members" or not if the class is marked as a runtime protocol. This information is irrelevant for non-runtime protocols; we can safely skip the risky introspection for them.
- Only do the risky getattr() calls in one place (the runtime_checkable class decorator), rather than in three places (_ProtocolMeta.__init__, _ProtocolMeta.__instancecheck__ and _ProtocolMeta.__subclasscheck__). This reduces the number of locations in typing.py where the risky introspection could go wrong.
- For runtime protocols, if determining whether a protocol member is callable or not fails, give a better error message. I think it's reasonable for us to reject runtime protocols that have members which raise strange exceptions when you try to access them. PEP-544 clearly states that all protocol member must be callable for issubclass() calls against the protocol to be valid -- and if a member raises when we try to access it, there's no way for us to figure out whether it's a callable member or not!

Lib/test/test_typing.py

@@ -3448,8 +3448,8 @@ class ProtocolTests(BaseTestCase):
 
         self.assertNotIn("__protocol_attrs__", vars(NonP))
         self.assertNotIn("__protocol_attrs__", vars(NonPR))
-        self.assertNotIn("__callable_proto_members_only__", vars(NonP))
-        self.assertNotIn("__callable_proto_members_only__", vars(NonPR))
+        self.assertNotIn("__non_callable_proto_members__", vars(NonP))
+        self.assertNotIn("__non_callable_proto_members__", vars(NonPR))
 
         self.assertEqual(get_protocol_members(P), {"x"})
         self.assertEqual(get_protocol_members(PR), {"meth"})
@@ -4105,6 +4105,7 @@ class ProtocolTests(BaseTestCase):
         self.assertNotIsInstance(42, ProtocolWithMixedMembers)
 
     def test_protocol_issubclass_error_message(self):
+        @runtime_checkable
         class Vec2D(Protocol):
             x: float
             y: float
@@ -4120,6 +4121,39 @@ class ProtocolTests(BaseTestCase):
         with self.assertRaisesRegex(TypeError, re.escape(expected_error_message)):
             issubclass(int, Vec2D)
 
+    def test_nonruntime_protocol_interaction_with_evil_classproperty(self):
+        class classproperty:
+            def __get__(self, instance, type):
+                raise RuntimeError("NO")
+
+        class Commentable(Protocol):
+            evil = classproperty()
+
+        # recognised as a protocol attr,
+        # but not actually accessed by the protocol metaclass
+        # (which would raise RuntimeError) for non-runtime protocols.
+        # See gh-113320
+        self.assertEqual(get_protocol_members(Commentable), {"evil"})
+
+    def test_runtime_protocol_interaction_with_evil_classproperty(self):
+        class CustomError(Exception): pass
+
+        class classproperty:
+            def __get__(self, instance, type):
+                raise CustomError
+
+        with self.assertRaises(TypeError) as cm:
+            @runtime_checkable
+            class Commentable(Protocol):
+                evil = classproperty()
+
+        exc = cm.exception
+        self.assertEqual(
+            exc.args[0],
+            "Failed to determine whether protocol member 'evil' is a method member"
+        )
+        self.assertIs(type(exc.__cause__), CustomError)
+
 
 class GenericTests(BaseTestCase):
 

Lib/typing.py

@@ -1670,7 +1670,7 @@ class _TypingEllipsis:
 _TYPING_INTERNALS = frozenset({
     '__parameters__', '__orig_bases__',  '__orig_class__',
     '_is_protocol', '_is_runtime_protocol', '__protocol_attrs__',
-    '__callable_proto_members_only__', '__type_params__',
+    '__non_callable_proto_members__', '__type_params__',
 })
 
 _SPECIAL_NAMES = frozenset({
@@ -1833,11 +1833,6 @@ class _ProtocolMeta(ABCMeta):
         super().__init__(*args, **kwargs)
         if getattr(cls, "_is_protocol", False):
             cls.__protocol_attrs__ = _get_protocol_attrs(cls)
-            # PEP 544 prohibits using issubclass()
-            # with protocols that have non-method members.
-            cls.__callable_proto_members_only__ = all(
-                callable(getattr(cls, attr, None)) for attr in cls.__protocol_attrs__
-            )
 
     def __subclasscheck__(cls, other):
         if cls is Protocol:
@@ -1846,25 +1841,23 @@ class _ProtocolMeta(ABCMeta):
             getattr(cls, '_is_protocol', False)
             and not _allow_reckless_class_checks()
         ):
-            if (
-                not cls.__callable_proto_members_only__
-                and cls.__dict__.get("__subclasshook__") is _proto_hook
-            ):
-                _type_check_issubclass_arg_1(other)
-                non_method_attrs = sorted(
-                    attr for attr in cls.__protocol_attrs__
-                    if not callable(getattr(cls, attr, None))
-                )
-                raise TypeError(
-                    "Protocols with non-method members don't support issubclass()."
-                    f" Non-method members: {str(non_method_attrs)[1:-1]}."
-                )
             if not getattr(cls, '_is_runtime_protocol', False):
                 _type_check_issubclass_arg_1(other)
                 raise TypeError(
                     "Instance and class checks can only be used with "
                     "@runtime_checkable protocols"
                 )
+            if (
+                # this attribute is set by @runtime_checkable:
+                cls.__non_callable_proto_members__
+                and cls.__dict__.get("__subclasshook__") is _proto_hook
+            ):
+                _type_check_issubclass_arg_1(other)
+                non_method_attrs = sorted(cls.__non_callable_proto_members__)
+                raise TypeError(
+                    "Protocols with non-method members don't support issubclass()."
+                    f" Non-method members: {str(non_method_attrs)[1:-1]}."
+                )
         return _abc_subclasscheck(cls, other)
 
     def __instancecheck__(cls, instance):
@@ -1892,7 +1885,8 @@ class _ProtocolMeta(ABCMeta):
                 val = getattr_static(instance, attr)
             except AttributeError:
                 break
-            if val is None and callable(getattr(cls, attr, None)):
+            # this attribute is set by @runtime_checkable:
+            if val is None and attr not in cls.__non_callable_proto_members__:
                 break
         else:
             return True
@@ -2114,6 +2108,22 @@ def runtime_checkable(cls):
         raise TypeError('@runtime_checkable can be only applied to protocol classes,'
                         ' got %r' % cls)
     cls._is_runtime_protocol = True
+    # PEP 544 prohibits using issubclass()
+    # with protocols that have non-method members.
+    # See gh-113320 for why we compute this attribute here,
+    # rather than in `_ProtocolMeta.__init__`
+    cls.__non_callable_proto_members__ = set()
+    for attr in cls.__protocol_attrs__:
+        try:
+            is_callable = callable(getattr(cls, attr, None))
+        except Exception as e:
+            raise TypeError(
+                f"Failed to determine whether protocol member {attr!r} "
+                "is a method member"
+            ) from e
+        else:
+            if not is_callable:
+                cls.__non_callable_proto_members__.add(attr)
     return cls
 
 

Misc/NEWS.d/next/Library/2023-12-22-11-30-57.gh-issue-113320.Vp5suS.rst

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+Fix regression in Python 3.12 where :class:`~typing.Protocol` classes that
+were not marked as :func:`runtime-checkable <typing.runtime_checkable>`
+would be unnecessarily introspected, potentially causing exceptions to be
+raised if the protocol had problematic members. Patch by Alex Waygood.